The best lip liner I have ever bought in terms of quality. It has great lasting power, writes smoothly and evenly, and the red apple color that I keep repurchasing works perfectly with my lipsticks.

Well, 4 stars for this product..
Overall, it writes perfectly as it is quite soft! The only negative is that when you try to sharpen it, the tip often ends up breaking or after sharpening, you don't have the expected fine tip but a thicker one that is sometimes inconvenient to use.
I recommend No. 3! It is perfect for all girls!

This specific pencil, while being quite soft for use as a lipstick, does not provide the desired angles that I would like for using it as a pencil. Additionally, its packaging is quite small for its price. I will not purchase it again

The 09 is a beautiful deep orange-red with pink undertones. It is creamy, long-lasting, and stays on for many hours. If there are any dry patches, it is good to apply a little lip balm underneath.