Terrible, one of the worst eyeliners I have ever tried. It doesn't release any color from the moment I bought it, so I couldn't use it at all and threw it away.

It didn't apply as nicely as I expected - I probably confused it with another one that I had tried and was perfect - it gave me a lot of difficulty and it was longer than I expected and wanted (it didn't resemble a marker but a hard brush), so I smudged it ten times and couldn't finally apply it well (it's also difficult to correct as it has intense color and smudges). However, I have to say that I'm not a makeup artist! I don't often wear eyeliner, but that's why I chose it to make it easier for me... unfortunately, it didn't. Maybe someone more experienced wouldn't have a problem with it!