Regardless of the price, very good. If we also consider the VFM then definitely excellent! I am looking for the curl that lasts as long as possible, without smudges, but is easy to remove. Compared to much more expensive or branded ones, this one separates and holds the lift longer (after using a hot curling iron of course), without clumps or a heavy, fake result, which you can create if you want with 2-3 layers. In terms of removal, it is of moderate difficulty with waterproof makeup remover, but it's worth it...

Positive impressions: natural result, good separation, very affordable.
Negative impressions: not the volume I want compared to other mascaras, not intense lifting and intense thick result, cleans quite difficult with waterproof mascara lotion, no matter how much you insist, you wake up with a little smudge under your eyes the next day. I will not prefer it again.

Finally, the opinion about mascaras is a very subjective thing.
This humble and affordable mascara is my absolute TOP!
I have lashes of normal length but without any curl. With a curler first and then this mascara, my lashes reach the sky, it separates them satisfactorily, gives plenty of volume, and its duration is excellent. It comfortably lasts until the evening (with early morning application). It doesn't clump, it doesn't smudge.
For its removal, I use coconut oil and I have no difficulty at all.
Usually, I buy 2-2.